Who’s the Greatest QB of All Time? Brady, Manning, or Montana?

[Sheba]

The GOAT debate among quarterbacks is endless! Some swear by Tom Brady’s seven Super Bowl rings, others love Peyton Manning’s precision, while Joe Montana remains undefeated in the big game. Who do you think deserves the title of the greatest QB ever? Are Super Bowl wins the defining factor, or do stats and leadership play a bigger role?

[Xavier]

For me, it’s hard to overlook Tom Brady. His seven Super Bowl wins and countless playoff appearances make him the most accomplished QB of all time. Peyton Manning was an incredible strategist with a remarkable career, but Brady’s longevity and consistency put him at the top. Joe Montana was also great, but Brady’s success across different teams and decades is unmatched.

[Sim-One]

For me, Tom Brady is the greatest QB of all time. His seven Super Bowl wins, unmatched longevity, and ability to perform in clutch moments set him apart. Peyton Manning and Joe Montana were incredible in their own rights—Manning with his football IQ and Montana with his perfect Super Bowl record—but Brady’s sustained success across different teams and eras gives him the edge.

[Jordan]

It’s tough, but I’d give the edge to Tom Brady as the greatest QB of all time. His seven Super Bowl rings, incredible longevity, and ability to perform under pressure set him apart. Peyton Manning was a genius at reading defenses and had a stellar career, while Joe Montana excelled in clutch moments with four Super Bowl wins. However, Brady’s sustained success and dominance in key moments make him the GOAT for me.