The Shift: Strategy or Overkill?

[Roman]

The defensive shift has sparked plenty of debate in recent years. Do you think it’s good strategy or does it take away from the game’s aesthetics? Should MLB consider banning shifts? What do you think about this controversial defensive tactic.

[Gary10]

Critics feel that it reduces the traditional aspect of the game, turning defense into a numbers game rather than relying on skill and intuition. Recent rule changes limiting the shift reflect the desire to restore balance, allowing for more action and encouraging a return to traditional defensive positioning.